The Slowcook at Spydog Farm The Slowcook at Spydog Farm

Accidental Buttermilk Pie

December 3rd, 2008 · 4 Comments · Posted in Recipes

What do you do when the dairy delivers a half-gallon of buttermilk by mistake?
Answer: Make buttermilk pie.
This was my wife’s inspiration. Although, if you had nailed my feet to the floor and doused me with hot coffee, I probably could have remembered there was something called “buttermilk pie.”
I love the flavor and consistency–somewhere between lemon meringue and coconut custard. It has the flakiest crust and just a bit of ever-so-crunchy caramelization on top. That’s because you start the pie cooking at 425 degrees, then lower the temperature.
The recipe comes from Martha Stewart’s Pies & Tarts. This book came out before people started to tire of Martha as knowing too much and I definitely recommend getting a copy, not just for the many excellent recipes (I take my wife’s word for it–she’s the baker in the family) but for the really dolled-up photo of a very young Martha published as an inset on the cover, just below a gorgeous heart-shaped raspberry tart. (Even then, Martha was getting her photo on the cover whenever possible, it seems. Is it fair to say she was using her looks to get ahead?)
We normally associate buttermilk pie or anything else with Southern cuisine. But apparently Martha–a Polish girl from New Jersey–knew a good thing when she tasted it.
For the pate brisee pie shell:
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon granulated sugar
1 cup cold unsalted butter, cut into small pieces
1/4 to 1/2 cup ice water.
Put flour, salt and sugar in the bowl of a food processor and chill. All ingredients must be cold before proceeding. Then add the pieces of butter and process for about 10 seconds, or until the mixture resembles coarse meal.
Add ice water, drop by drop, through the feed tube with the machine running, just until the dough holds together without being wet or sticky. Do not process more than 30 seconds. Test dough by squeezing a small amount together. If it is crumbly, add a bit more water.
Turn dough out onto a large piece of plastic wrap. Grasping the ends of the plastic wrap with your hands, press the dough into a flat circle with your fists. Rolling will be easier if the pastry is chilled as a ball. Wrap the dough in the plastic and chill for at least an hour.
Use vegetable cooking spray to lightly butter a pie plate or tart pan. On a lightly floured board, roll out the pastry to a thickness of 1/8 inch. Place the pastry in the tart pan or pie plate and press it into the bottom edges and along the sides. Trim pastry using scissors or a sharp paring knife. Crimp or decorate the edges of the pastry, if desired, using your favorite method. Chill the pastry-lined pan until ready to use.
For the filling:
1/2 cups granulated sugar
3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
4 eggs, lightly beaten
1/2 cup unsalted butter, melted and cooled slightly
1 cup buttermilk
zest of 1 lemon
1 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
freshly grated nutmeg to taste
For the glaze:
1 egg yolk with beaten with 2 teaspoons water
Preheat oven to 425 degrees.
Combine the sugar and flour in a large mixing bowl. Add the beaten eggs and mix well. Stir in butter and buttermilk. Stir in lemon rind and juice, vanilla and nutmeg, and pour into the pie shell. Brush the edge of the pie crust with the egg glaze. Place the pie in the center of the oven for 15 minutes. Lower the heat to 350 degrees and continue to bake for approximately 40 minutes, until the filling is set. Remove from the oven and serve at room temperature.
You’ll like this so much you’ll want the dairy to deliver buttermilk by mistake more often.

Leave a Comment

Please note: Your comment may have to wait for approval to be published to ensure that we don't accidentally publish "spam". We thank you for understanding.


  • Anonymous

    What dairy do you use to get fresh milk delivered? How much, etc.?

  • Ed Bruske

    Anon, please don’t post anonymously. You can find previous posts about our dairy delivery using the search feature at the top of the page.

  • mpinard

    What a visual stunner of a site! And I just hit this page because it was the first recipe listed and thus a representational sample, but I like it already. I made buttermilk pie once, on purpose, because the cookbook I used (definitely not Martha- I boycott her) said it would make any Southern woman “quiver in her hoop skirt” which enticed me. It was pretty good- you describe the texture very accurately- but there was just so much sugar!
    Thanks for a great public site.

  • Ed Bruske

    M, you’re welcome! Please stop by often.